October 7, 2026
Silence Is Not Always Fidelity: The Impact of Lekelefac’s Advocacy on Asongu’s Public Theology

By Fr. George Gonzalez

The development of a theologian is not shaped by books and ideas alone. Sometimes another scholar does not provide new ideas but gives someone the courage to say publicly what he has already come to believe. This is an important dimension of the relationship between George Chrysostom Nchumbonga Lekelefac and Januarius Asongu.

Asongu’s critical disposition long predates his public theology. During his seminary years, he acquired a reputation as a critic and a “free thinker”—a description that was hardly complimentary within that environment. His willingness to question accepted assumptions contributed to the tensions surrounding his eventual departure from seminary formation.

Yet leaving seminary did not mean abandoning the Church. Asongu retained a profound attachment to Catholicism. Indeed, that attachment produced an enduring tension: the same critical instinct that enabled him to recognize institutional problems competed with an equally powerful instinct to protect a Church he loved.

He feared that publicly exposing its failures might inflict additional wounds upon an institution already wounded.

George Lekelefac helped change that calculation.

Two Cameroonian Former Seminarians

The connection is especially significant because Lekelefac is also a former seminarian. Both men are Cameroonian and experienced formation within the institutional and spiritual culture of the Catholic Church. They understood from within the habits of obedience, reverence for ecclesiastical authority, fraternity, and loyalty cultivated through seminary formation.

Lekelefac, however, became particularly known for safeguarding advocacy and criticism of clerical sexual abuse. His work emphasizes the protection of vulnerable persons, accountability, canonical justice, and the responsibilities of ecclesiastical authorities.

His example presented Asongu with another understanding of fidelity. Criticism of failures within the Church need not constitute hostility toward the Church. Sometimes exposing what wounds an institution is part of attempting to heal it.

The lesson was simple but consequential: silence is not always fidelity.

When Advocacy Became Concrete

Their relationship eventually moved beyond intellectual encouragement.

Through his safeguarding advocacy in Cameroon, Lekelefac interviewed women who reported experiences of abuse involving clerics. Recognizing that some needed psychological support, he reached out to Asongu.

The choice was deliberate. Asongu is a counseling psychologist, holds the LACMH credential, and has authored numerous works in psychology and counseling. Lekelefac therefore approached him not merely as a fellow Cameroonian, Catholic scholar, or former seminarian, but as a mental-health professional who could assist people he encountered through his advocacy.

He asked Asongu to provide pro bono counseling support to some of these women. Asongu agreed.

The encounter transformed an institutional question into a profoundly human one. Behind discussions of canon law, episcopal responsibility, clericalism, and ecclesial reputation were people carrying psychological, relational, and spiritual wounds.

A new question consequently confronted Asongu. Instead of asking only, Will speaking critically further wound the Church?, he also had to ask: What happens to wounded people when those capable of speaking remain silent?

From the “Free Thinker” to Public Theology

Lekelefac’s influence should not be mistaken for intellectual dependence. He did not create Asongu’s critical disposition. Seminary authorities had recognized that disposition decades earlier when the label “free thinker” was attached to him.

What Lekelefac helped change was Asongu’s willingness to exercise that critical freedom publicly in relation to the Church.

There is an intriguing reciprocity here. Lekelefac’s safeguarding advocacy helped embolden Asongu’s public theological voice. Asongu subsequently developed a broader philosophical and theological architecture—particularly Critical-Liberative Theology—that Lekelefac himself would later engage, interpret, and help communicate.

The relationship is therefore better understood as a dialogue between two independently developing intellectual projects than simply as that between a thinker and his commentator.

Fidelity Through Truth

There is a striking continuity in Asongu’s journey. The seminarian once criticized as a “free thinker” did not cease asking difficult questions. What changed was his understanding of when those questions needed to become public.

His earlier restraint and his later criticism arose, paradoxically, from the same source: concern for the Church.

Lekelefac helped illuminate the difference between protecting the Church and protecting the Church from truth.

Sometimes fidelity requires defense. Sometimes prudence requires silence. But when silence leaves suffering unheard, authority insufficiently accountable, or necessary reform postponed, fidelity may require speaking.

For two Cameroonian former seminarians who continued to love the Church that formed them, truth-telling need not represent abandonment of the Church. It may instead become an act of responsibility toward its healing.