October 7, 2026
WHEN TRUTH BECOMES A FORM OF FIDELITY: A Letter of Gratitude and Theological Reflection to Father George Gonzalez, PhD on Silence, Conscience, Safeguarding, Critical-Liberative Theology, and the Transformative Encounter between Januarius Asongu and Nchumbonga George Lekelefac.

 By Nchumbonga George Lekelefac; great-grandson of Pa Fuadonawoung—that legendary interlocutor of thrones of Lebang, the one whose voice made Fons listen, whose counsel compelled them to sit upright; B.Phil. (Mexico); S.T.B. (Rome); J.C.L./M.C.L. (Ottawa); Doctorandus, University of Münster, Germany; International Advocate for the Oppressed, Voice of the Voiceless, Defender of Fundamental Human Rights, Canon Lawyer/Jurist, Friend to the Vulnerable, and Lover of No Oppressor/Tyrant

Motto: “Not merely to recount what has been, but to share in moulding what should be.”— Prof. Dr. Bernard Nsokika Fonlon

Dear Father George Gonzalez, PhD (Master of Theology and Religion and a Ph.D. in Psychology) priest, chaplain, and therapist for the Diocese of Brownsville, Texas, USA

INTRODUCTION

I write to you with gratitude, but also with a certain sense of responsibility. Your article, “Silence Is Not Always Fidelity: The Impact of Lekelefac’s Advocacy on Asongu’s Public Theology,” is generous toward me, insightful concerning Januarius Asongu, and, more importantly, provocative concerning the vocation of intellectuals within the Church. You have placed before us a question that cannot be answered superficially: What does fidelity to the Church mean when the truth about the Church becomes painful? This question is not theoretical. It concerns priests. It concerns theologians. It concerns psychologists and therapists. It concerns canon lawyers. It concerns bishops and religious superiors. It concerns former seminarians. It concerns victims and survivors. It concerns families. It concerns Catholic institutions. And it concerns every person who loves the Church enough to desire that she become ever more faithful to the Gospel she proclaims. I therefore receive your reflection not simply as a compliment but as a serious invitation to examine the deeper meaning of advocacy.

1.    A LETTER OF GRATITUDE

Dear Father George, Thank you. That is the simplest and perhaps most appropriate beginning. Thank you for seeing in my advocacy something larger than controversy. Thank you for understanding that advocacy, when genuinely motivated by the dignity of the human person, cannot be reduced to opposition against an institution. Thank you for recognizing the importance of the relationship between Januarius Asongu and myself. Thank you for identifying the role that encounters between intellectuals can play in the development of public thought. And thank you particularly for identifying something that I consider fundamental: the distinction between loving the Church and protecting every action performed by members of the Church. These are not the same thing. One can love the Church profoundly while criticizing ecclesiastical decisions. One can defend the dignity of priesthood while demanding accountability from priests. One can honor bishops while questioning episcopal decisions. One can defend the institutional Church while insisting that institutions must never become shelters for injustice. Indeed, authentic love sometimes makes criticism unavoidable. The person who does not care can remain indifferent. The person who loves is often compelled to ask difficult questions. That is why I appreciate your title. Silence is not always fidelity. Sometimes fidelity speaks. Sometimes fidelity cries. Sometimes fidelity documents. Sometimes fidelity investigates. Sometimes fidelity accompanies the wounded. Sometimes fidelity demands accountability. Sometimes fidelity goes to the places where respectable society would rather not look. And sometimes fidelity simply refuses to allow another human being to disappear into silence.

2.    TWO FORMER SEMINARIANS AND THE MEMORY OF FORMATION

Your description of Januarius Asongu and myself as two Cameroonian former seminarians is particularly significant. Seminary formation leaves a profound imprint. Even when a person leaves the seminary, the seminary does not necessarily leave the person. It leaves behind habits of prayer, theological categories, ecclesial vocabulary, relationships, memories, questions, wounds, friendships, intellectual disciplines, and sometimes unresolved tensions. It teaches obedience. It teaches reverence. It teaches fraternity. It teaches ecclesial identity. It teaches the meaning of priesthood. It introduces the seminarian to Scripture, theology, philosophy, canon law, liturgy, spirituality, and pastoral responsibility. But formation also confronts a person with authority. And this is where intellectual conscience becomes important. The seminarian must eventually learn the difference between obedience and intellectual surrender. Obedience does not mean that a person ceases to think. Ecclesial communion does not require intellectual paralysis. Reverence does not mean that questions are forbidden. A Church that possesses the fullness of truth has nothing to fear from sincere questions. Indeed, the Catholic intellectual tradition has always understood that faith and reason are not enemies. The Christian intellectual does not ask questions because he has ceased to believe. He may ask questions precisely because he believes that truth matters. This is particularly important in the development of Januarius Asongu. The label “free thinker,” as you observed, was not simply an intellectual description. Within a seminary environment, such descriptions can carry institutional implications. The free thinker can become perceived as the difficult seminarian. The questioner can become perceived as disobedient. The critic can become perceived as disloyal. Yet history repeatedly demonstrates that institutions sometimes need precisely those people who are willing to ask the questions everyone else has learned to avoid.

3.    THE “FREE THINKER” AND THE VOCATION OF INTELLECTUAL CONSCIENCE

I was particularly struck by your observation that Asongu's critical disposition existed long before our relationship. That clarification is important. I did not manufacture Januarius Asongu's intellect. I did not create his critical consciousness. I did not give him his philosophical temperament. I did not invent his theological questions. I encountered a person who already possessed these characteristics. This distinction matters because intellectual influence should never be confused with intellectual ownership. No genuine scholar should claim to have created another scholar's thought simply because his friendship, advocacy, criticism, or encouragement helped create circumstances in which that thought became more public. The intellectual relationship is more subtle. One person may provide courage. Another provides conceptual language. One provides experience. Another provides interpretation. One asks the question. Another develops the framework. One documents the wound. Another develops the theology of healing. One encounters the suffering individual. Another understands the psychological consequences. One brings the experience of institutional life. Another analyzes its structures. Thus, intellectual development is often dialogical. The philosopher Martin Buber's famous understanding of the “I-Thou” relationship offers a useful conceptual lens here. Human beings become themselves through encounters. We are not isolated intellectual machines. We become more fully conscious through relationships. The same can happen in theology. A theologian may possess an idea privately for years until an encounter forces him to recognize its public implications. That, I believe, is part of what you are identifying in the relationship between Asongu and myself.

4.    ADVOCACY IS NOT HOSTILITY

There is an unfortunate tendency within ecclesial environments to equate criticism with hostility. This is one of the central issues your article raises. To criticize the Church is not necessarily to hate the Church. To expose a problem is not necessarily to attack the Church. To demand accountability is not necessarily to reject ecclesial authority. To advocate for victims is not necessarily to undermine priesthood. Indeed, one could make the opposite argument. Responsible criticism can be an expression of ecclesial commitment. A person who truly loves an institution may desire that the institution live according to its own highest principles. A person who loves the priesthood may refuse to tolerate conduct that disgraces priesthood. A person who reveres episcopal authority may insist that authority be exercised according to justice. A person who loves canon law may demand that canonical procedures be respected. A person who values Catholic moral teaching may insist that the Church herself apply her moral principles internally. This is not rebellion. It is accountability. The Church teaches the dignity of every human person. Therefore, the victim of abuse possesses dignity. The Church teaches the protection of the vulnerable. Therefore, vulnerable persons must be protected. The Church teaches truth. Therefore, truth must not be sacrificed merely to preserve institutional reputation. The Church teaches justice. Therefore, justice must not be suspended simply because the accused is powerful. The Church teaches mercy. Therefore, victims must not be reduced to inconvenient problems.

5.    THE WOUNDED PERSON BEHIND THE INSTITUTIONAL QUESTION

Your discussion of the women whom I encountered through safeguarding advocacy is perhaps the most important part of your essay. It reminds us that safeguarding is not fundamentally about institutions. It is about persons. Every institutional discussion eventually reaches a human face. Behind the words “clerical abuse” there is a person. Behind “canonical procedure” there may be a wounded family. Behind “episcopal accountability” there may be a person who has waited years to be heard. Behind “institutional reputation” there may be someone who wonders whether anybody believes her. Behind “pastoral prudence” there may be someone asking: “Who will listen to me?” That is why the encounter with psychology becomes so important. When I approached Asongu concerning psychological support, I was not seeking merely another intellectual voice. I was seeking help for human beings. This distinction is critical. Theological reflection can explain suffering. Canon law can regulate procedures. Sociology can analyze structures. Psychology can help us understand trauma. Pastoral ministry can accompany the person. But the wounded person must remain at the center. Otherwise our scholarship becomes detached from the very human reality it claims to understand.

6.    WHY I TURNED TO ASOΝGU

My decision to approach Asongu was therefore not accidental. He possessed an intellectual and professional combination particularly relevant to the circumstances. He was a fellow Cameroonian. He was a Catholic intellectual.  He was a former seminarian. He possessed a critical theological disposition. And he was also a counseling psychologist. Your description of his professional competence therefore helps illuminate the significance of the encounter. The request that he provide pro bono counseling support was, in its essence, an appeal to professional solidarity. The question was not: “What can Asongu say about the Church?” The question was: “What can Asongu do for a wounded person?” This is a profoundly different question. The second question takes us from theory to service. It transforms theology into pastoral responsibility. It transforms intellectual concern into human accompaniment. It makes the wounded person visible. And this is precisely where psychology and theology can meet.

7.    FATHER GEORGE GONZALEZ: A MINISTRY AT THE INTERSECTION OF SPIRITUALITY AND PSYCHOLOGY

It is particularly fitting, Father George, that you should have written this reflection. You are not approaching these questions merely as an external observer. You yourself embody an interdisciplinary vocation. You are Father George Gonzalez, PhD, holding a Master of Theology and Religion and a PhD in Psychology, and serving as a priest, chaplain, and therapist for the Diocese of Brownsville Catholic Church. Your ministry extends beyond the sanctuary. You provide prison ministry to prisons and jails in the Rio Grande Valley. You also teach part-time for Wayland Baptist University. Your work therefore occupies a remarkable intersection: 1) spirituality, 2) theology, 3) psychology, 4) pastoral care, 5) clinical practice, 6) chaplaincy, 7) education, 8) rehabilitation, 9) and human transformation. This makes your reflection particularly meaningful. You understand that a human being cannot always be divided neatly into “spiritual,” “psychological,” “social,” and “institutional” categories. The human person is integrated. The wounded person prays. The traumatized person thinks. The prisoner possesses dignity. The client has spiritual questions. The survivor has psychological needs. The person experiencing institutional injustice may also experience a crisis of faith. Your integrated approach recognizes precisely this complexity. You bring, as your own professional vocation demonstrates, an integrated approach in a spiritual, clinical, therapeutic, and pastoral direction to program development. You support the need for education for the public, while also emphasizing the importance of assessing a client's readiness for change and addressing the needs and issues of clients and inmates. That perspective adds another dimension to your essay. You understand that transformation cannot be reduced to condemnation. People need truth. But they also need accompaniment. They need accountability. But they also need opportunities for healing. They need justice. But they also need structures capable of facilitating change.

8.    FROM SAFEGUARDING TO THEOLOGY

Safeguarding is sometimes treated as a specialized administrative field. That is insufficient. Safeguarding is theological. It begins with anthropology. What is the human person? What is human dignity? What does it mean that every human being is created in the image and likeness of God? What does it mean for the Church to proclaim herself a sacramental sign of salvation? And what happens when an institution entrusted with protecting human dignity becomes implicated in the violation of that dignity? These are theological questions. The Church cannot answer them merely through public-relations strategies. Nor can she answer them solely through administrative procedures. She must answer them through conversion. The Gospel requires the Church to look upon the vulnerable not as institutional liabilities but as persons whose dignity imposes obligations upon everyone who encounters them. Safeguarding therefore becomes an expression of the Church's sacramental identity. The Church must become what she proclaims.

9.    THEOLOGY AFTER THE WOUND

The wounded person changes theology. This is one of the great lessons that emerged from my encounters with people affected by ecclesial failures. Before encountering suffering, one can speak abstractly. After encountering suffering, abstraction becomes morally insufficient. Theological statements acquire flesh. The word “justice” acquires a face. The word “mercy” acquires a story. The word “accountability” acquires consequences. The word “healing” acquires a human name. This is why I believe that theology must listen. A theology that does not listen risks becoming an intellectual architecture without pastoral foundations. The Church cannot simply speak to wounded people. She must also allow wounded people to speak to the Church. Their testimony becomes part of the Church's examination of conscience. Their stories can expose institutional weaknesses. Their pain can reveal structures requiring reform. Their courage can become an invitation to conversion. Their survival can become a testimony to human resilience.

10. ASOΝGU'S PUBLIC THEOLOGY AND THE COURAGE TO SPEAK

Your central thesis concerning Asongu deserves serious consideration. You argue that my advocacy helped alter his calculation concerning public criticism. That is a generous interpretation, but I believe there is truth in it. The important point is not that I gave Asongu his theology. Rather, perhaps I helped create circumstances in which he could see that his theological concerns had practical consequences. The private critic can remain private. The public theologian cannot. Public theology requires courage because it enters the contested space between ideas and institutions. The public theologian asks: What does this doctrine mean for society? What does this principle require from institutions? What does faith demand in the presence of injustice? How should theology respond when the marginalized are ignored? What happens when authority becomes detached from accountability? These questions inevitably bring theology into conversation with public life. That is where Asongu's critical disposition becomes significant. The “free thinker” becomes the public theologian. The questioner becomes the analyst. The critic becomes the architect. The private intellectual becomes a public voice.

11. CRITICAL-LIBERATIVE THEOLOGY

Your article rightly identifies the subsequent development of Asongu's broader philosophical and theological architecture, particularly his work in Critical-Liberative Theology. I have not understood my relationship with Asongu as one in which I simply received his ideas. Rather, it has been reciprocal. He developed concepts. I encountered them through my own experiences. I interpreted them through advocacy. I engaged them through ecclesial questions. And our respective intellectual projects entered into dialogue. This reciprocity is important. Critical thought should not become another form of intellectual domination. Liberative theology should not liberate some voices while silencing others. Theology must continually examine itself. Who speaks? Who is spoken about? Who is absent? Who has the authority to interpret? Who has historically been ignored? Who suffers from the consequences of theological decisions? These questions are indispensable. A genuinely liberative theology must therefore have an epistemological dimension. It must ask not only: “What is truth?” but also: “Whose experience has been permitted to count in the search for truth?”

12. THE CHURCH DOES NOT NEED LESS TRUTH

There are moments when institutional fear produces the temptation to reduce truth. This is dangerous. The Church does not need less truth. She needs deeper truth. She does not need fewer questions. She needs better questions. She does not need intellectual uniformity. She needs communion capable of accommodating legitimate intellectual diversity. The Catholic tradition has survived centuries precisely because it has possessed the intellectual resources to confront difficult questions. Theology develops because questions arise. Canon law develops because pastoral realities change. Moral theology develops because human circumstances challenge simplistic formulations. Biblical scholarship develops because the Church continues to explore the richness of revelation. Pastoral theology develops because human suffering changes form. Therefore criticism, when exercised responsibly, can become an instrument of ecclesial purification.

13. THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CRITICIZING THE CHURCH AND ABANDONING THE CHURCH

There is an important distinction that deserves emphasis. Criticism is not abandonment. A person may criticize the Church because he has left the Church. But another person may criticize the Church because he desperately wants her to remain faithful to Christ. These motives must not be confused. When I advocate for safeguarding, I do not understand myself as an enemy of Catholicism. I understand the advocacy as an expression of my commitment to the dignity of the human person. I do not believe that the Church becomes weaker when abuse is exposed. I believe she becomes weaker when abuse is hidden. I do not believe that the Church loses credibility when accountability occurs. I believe she loses credibility when accountability is avoided. I do not believe that truth destroys ecclesial communion. I believe that falsehood ultimately does. Communion built upon silence is fragile. Communion built upon truth has the possibility of becoming authentic.

14. THE TEMPTATION OF INSTITUTIONAL SELF-PROTECTION

Every institution possesses a natural instinct for self-preservation. This is not necessarily sinister. Institutions need continuity. They need trust. They need reputation. They need stability. But the instinct for institutional self-preservation becomes morally dangerous when institutional reputation is placed above human dignity. At that moment, the institution begins to protect itself from the people it exists to serve. This is precisely why safeguarding requires independent moral vigilance. An institution cannot be its own unquestioned judge. It needs accountability. It needs external scrutiny. It needs transparent procedures. It needs professional expertise. It needs mechanisms for reporting. It needs psychological care. It needs pastoral accompaniment. It needs canonical responsibility. And above all, it needs a culture in which the vulnerable person is believed to matter.

15. THE ROLE OF PSYCHOLOGY IN ECCLESIAL HEALING

Your own ministry makes this chapter especially important. As a priest, chaplain, therapist, and psychologist, you understand something that purely institutional approaches can overlook: human beings carry wounds in their minds, bodies, relationships, memories, and spiritual lives. A person can leave an abusive environment physically while remaining psychologically imprisoned by what happened. A person can forgive and still require therapy. A person can return to prayer and still experience trauma. A person can remain Catholic and still struggle with the institution. A person can love God while distrusting ecclesiastical authority. These realities require nuance. Psychology therefore does not replace theology. Nor does theology replace psychology. They can cooperate. The therapist can help the person understand trauma. The theologian can help the community understand meaning. The pastor can accompany the person spiritually. The canonist can address institutional responsibility. The advocate can ensure that the person's voice is not erased. The result should not be fragmentation but integration. This is precisely why your own professional ministry gives special credibility to the insight contained in your article.

16. THE PRISON, THE SEMINARY, AND THE HUMAN PERSON

Your prison ministry in the Rio Grande Valley offers another profound lens through which to understand our discussion. The prison is perhaps one of the clearest places in which society is forced to confront the question of human dignity. The prisoner has committed an offense, perhaps a grave one. Yet the prisoner remains human. Justice does not eliminate dignity. Accountability does not eliminate humanity. Punishment does not erase the possibility of transformation. This insight has implications for ecclesial accountability as well. Accountability and mercy are not necessarily opposites. Justice and pastoral care are not enemies. Truth and compassion can coexist. A person can be held responsible without being stripped of dignity. Institutions can be challenged without being hated. The Church can confront misconduct without ceasing to be the Church. This integrated perspective is one of the reasons I value your reflection. Your professional world refuses simplistic binaries.

17. EDUCATION AS A FORM OF PREVENTION

You also emphasize the need for public education. This deserves special attention. Safeguarding cannot be reduced to responding to abuse after it happens. Prevention requires education. People must understand boundaries. Communities must recognize warning signs. Children and vulnerable adults must know that they have rights. Parents must understand reporting mechanisms. Clergy must understand professional and pastoral boundaries. Religious institutions must develop cultures of transparency. Seminaries must teach future priests not merely how to administer sacraments but how to understand power, vulnerability, psychological development, boundaries, accountability, and pastoral ethics. Theological formation must be integrated with human formation. This is especially important because clerical formation involves authority. The priest becomes a person to whom others entrust their consciences. That trust is sacred. It must never be exploited.

18. FROM FIDELITY TO CONVERSION

The deepest lesson of your article, Father George, may ultimately be the meaning of conversion. The Church continually calls people to conversion. But institutions can sometimes speak about conversion as though it were only something individuals outside the institution require. The Church herself must continually examine her conscience. Ecclesial conversion means asking: Where have we failed? Whom have we wounded? Whom have we ignored? Whom have we silenced? Where have procedures failed? Where has power become unaccountable? Where has clericalism replaced service? Where has institutional reputation been placed above human dignity? Where has fear prevented truth? These are painful questions. But Christianity is not afraid of examination. The cross itself is an exposure of human violence. The resurrection is God's response to that violence. Therefore, the Church need not fear the truth. She must fear becoming incapable of hearing it.

19. THE BEAUTY OF INTELLECTUAL FRIENDSHIP

Your article has also reminded me that intellectual relationships can possess a profound beauty. Januarius Asongu and I did not need to become identical thinkers. Indeed, intellectual friendship becomes more valuable when two people retain their individuality. We can challenge one another. We can interpret one another. We can disagree. We can sharpen one another. We can learn from one another. And we can recognize that intellectual development is never entirely solitary. Perhaps that is one of the great lessons of scholarship. The scholar does not merely produce ideas. The scholar enters into a conversation extending beyond himself. Asongu's work has its own intellectual trajectory. My advocacy has its own trajectory. Yet at particular moments those trajectories intersected. Your essay has captured one of those intersections. For that, I am grateful.

20. SILENCE IS NOT ALWAYS FIDELITY

And so, Father George, I return to the title you gave your reflection: Silence Is Not Always Fidelity. I believe the sentence deserves to become more than the title of an article. It can become an examination of conscience. There are times when silence is fidelity. Jesus Himself knew silence. The contemplative tradition knows silence. Prayer knows silence. Discernment requires silence. Prudence sometimes demands silence. Not every accusation should become a public spectacle. Not every disagreement requires publication. Not every wound should be exposed without regard for privacy. Not every truth should be spoken without charity. But there are also moments when silence becomes morally impossible. When a vulnerable person is crying for help, silence may become abandonment. When injustice is known, silence may become complicity. When institutional power suppresses truth, silence may become cooperation with injustice. When victims are ignored, silence can deepen the wound. When reform is necessary, silence can postpone healing. Therefore, the mature question is not: “Should I speak or should I remain silent?” The mature question is: “What does love require of me at this moment?” That is a much harder question. It requires prudence. It requires courage. It requires humility. It requires discernment. It requires knowledge. It requires charity. It requires an understanding of consequences. And above all, it requires a conscience oriented toward truth. Perhaps that is what happened in the encounter you describe. Perhaps my advocacy did not create Asongu's voice. Perhaps it simply helped convince him that his voice had a responsibility to enter the public square. And perhaps his subsequent theological work, in turn, helped provide intellectual language through which advocacy could be interpreted more deeply. That is not intellectual dependency. It is intellectual reciprocity. It is the meeting of experience and reflection. It is the encounter between wound and theology. It is the dialogue between advocacy and interpretation. It is the conversation between the person who says, “Something is wrong,” and the theologian who asks, “What does this mean?” And perhaps the answer is ultimately very simple: Truth is not the enemy of the Church. Truth is one of the conditions of her healing. The Church does not become less Catholic when she listens to the wounded. She becomes more faithful to Christ. She does not become less authoritative when she accepts accountability. She becomes more credible. She does not become weaker when scholars ask difficult questions. She becomes intellectually alive. She does not betray tradition when she examines her failures. She becomes capable of transmitting tradition faithfully. And she does not abandon communion when she permits responsible criticism. She discovers the difference between communion and conformity.

Dear Father Dr. George,

Your own ministry gives you a privileged position from which to appreciate these realities. You serve as priest. You serve as chaplain. You serve as therapist. You serve those in prisons and jails in the Rio Grande Valley. You teach. You engage psychology. You engage theology. You work toward readiness for change. You advocate education. You seek to address the needs of clients and inmates. You therefore understand that healing requires more than condemnation. Healing requires truth, but also accompaniment. It requires accountability, but also transformation. It requires justice, but also human dignity. It requires institutional reform, but also individual conversion. Your reflection on Asongu and myself therefore becomes part of a much larger conversation. It is a conversation about what happens when theology encounters suffering. It is a conversation about what happens when scholarship encounters responsibility. It is a conversation about what happens when former seminarians encounter the limitations of institutions they once hoped to serve. It is a conversation about what happens when the Church's own principles are turned back upon the Church herself. And perhaps most importantly, it is a conversation about what happens when two people decide that loving the Church does not require them to stop asking questions. For that reason, Father George, I receive your essay with gratitude. You have given me an opportunity to look back upon an important intellectual and pastoral relationship and to recognize that the history of ideas is also the history of human encounters. You have reminded us that a theologian may need an advocate. An advocate may need a theologian. A victim may need a therapist. A therapist may need theology. A priest may need criticism. An institution may need accountability. And the Church may need the courage to listen to those who love her enough to tell her the truth. Let me therefore conclude with a conviction that I hope will remain at the heart of this entire reflection: I do not advocate because I have ceased to love the Church. I advocate because I believe the Church is capable of becoming more faithful to Christ. I do not speak because I believe myself infallible. I speak because silence is not always the most responsible response to suffering. I do not criticize because I wish to destroy. I criticize because I believe that institutions can be purified. I do not defend victims because I wish to weaken the Church. I defend them because the Church herself teaches that the vulnerable must be protected. And I do not believe that truth is an enemy of ecclesial communion. I believe that communion without truth is ultimately fragile. Your title therefore becomes, for me, both a theological proposition and a personal examination of conscience: Silence Is Not Always Fidelity. Sometimes fidelity whispers. Sometimes fidelity waits. Sometimes fidelity prays. Sometimes fidelity forgives. But sometimes— fidelity speaks. Sometimes fidelity documents. Sometimes fidelity challenges authority. Sometimes fidelity stands beside the wounded. Sometimes fidelity asks uncomfortable questions. Sometimes fidelity refuses institutional amnesia. Sometimes fidelity insists that the Church cannot heal what she refuses to acknowledge. And sometimes the most profoundly ecclesial act a person can perform is to tell the truth with sufficient love that the truth itself becomes an invitation to conversion.

Father Dr. George, thank you for having the courage to write about this. Thank you for seeing the relationship between Asongu and myself as an intellectual and human encounter rather than merely an exchange of ideas. Thank you for reminding us that advocacy can influence theology without possessing it. Thank you for reminding us that theology can interpret advocacy without replacing it. And thank you for demonstrating through your own ministry that the human person must always remain at the center of our spiritual, clinical, therapeutic, educational, and pastoral endeavors. May your priestly ministry continue to bring together the altar and the counseling room, the classroom and the prison, theology and psychology, justice and mercy, truth and healing. And may the Church increasingly discover that the question is not whether she should protect herself from criticism, but whether she can learn to recognize, within responsible criticism, an invitation to become more faithful to the Gospel.

With profound gratitude, respect, fraternity, and appreciation,

Nchumbonga George Lekelefac, PhD (c.), Doctorandus, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität, Münster, Germany. Catholic Writer, Researcher, Advocate, and Canonical Scholar, Voice for the Vulnerable and Defender of Fundamental Human Dignity

“Not merely to recount what has been, but to share in moulding what should be.”

— Prof. Dr. Bernard Nsokika Fonlon

Email: nchumbong@yahoo.com